American Idol Ladies Top 10

February 28, 2007 |

The top 10 ladies sang on American Idol tonight and I do believe as a group they weren’t quite as good as the guys last night. However, I do think the best girl Idols are better than the best guy Idols. The less talented ladies really stood out tonight though like Antonella Barba, I mean, she can’t sing!

Here’s how the show went down with the American Idol Girls tonight:

Gina Glocksen - The girl can sing and I don’t care what Simon says Gina sang Heart from the heart and she was edgy. She rocked!

Alaina Alexander - Alaina sang I’m Not Ready To Make Nice by the Dixie Chicks (who everybody can’t stand right about now) and she did a pretty good job considering how she sounded last week. I don’t think she was as bad as Randy and Simon made her out to be.

Lakisha Jones - She started out a little bit nervous tonight with her rendition of Midnight Train To Georgia, but she pulled it together and was still in the top 2 contestants tonight.

Melinda Doolittle - She was the best performer of the night and looked totally professional. Her rendition of My Funny Valentine was first class, Simon loved it and said she was a breath of fresh air. You go girl!

Antonella Barba - Why is she still here? She butchered Celine Dion’s Because You Loved Me. It was flat and seriously boring and it’s a travesty that she made it as far as she did when girls like Baylie Brown had way more talent. By, by Antonella.

Jordin Sparks - With all of the other top ladies singing tonight, I don’t think Jordin sounded that good. Yes, she has talent, but I think she can do better.

Stephanie Edwards - This is the first time I’ve actually heard Stephanie sing and I think she did okay even though I don’t like Beyonce. The song was way to busy for me.

Haley Scarnato - She sang Queen Of The Night, but didn’t sound like a queen. Her performance was great, but her vocals weren’t. I think she’s going home with Antonella.

Leslie Hunt - The jazz vocal run at the end of her didn’t sound good. There are only a few singers in the world that can do that and if you aren’t one of them, you shouldn’t try.

Sabrina Sloan - Sabrina looks like an American Idol and she sang like one tonight. Her Whitney rendition was incredible and she exudes confidence. If she plays her cards right she could win the whole thing.

So, who’s going home on Thursday? My prediction is that Antonella Barba and Haley Scarnato will be voted off. Antonella was pitiful and Haley just doesn’t have the voice to compete.

Tune in tomorrow for the results.

Alan

Tags: antonella barba, gina glocksen, dixie chicks, melinda doolittle, sabrina sloan, lakisha jones, baylie brown